Overview

  • How many polynomials have a specified list of factor degrees?
  • Why do permutations give the limiting proportions?
  • Which short intervals have the same factorization statistics?
  • How can a family have symmetric monodromy when individual splitting fields are cyclic?

Factorization type

For a monic squarefree polynomial of degree nn, let mjm_j be the number of its irreducible factors of degree jj. Its factorization type is the partition λ=1m12m2⋯\lambda=1^{m_1}2^{m_2}\cdots, where ∑jmj=n\sum j m_j=n. Frobenius acts on its roots with exactly these cycle lengths.

Put zλ=∏j≥1jmjmj!z_\lambda=\prod_{j\ge1}j^{m_j}m_j!. A uniformly chosen permutation in SnS_n has cycle type λ\lambda with probability 1/zλ1/z_\lambda: arrange the symbols into cycles, divide by rotations within each cycle, and divide by the order of cycles of equal length.

References 1

Exact counting

Let Nq(j)N_q(j) be the number of monic irreducible polynomials of degree jj. Unique factorization gives the exact formula #{f monic squarefree of type λ}=∏j≥1(Nq(j)mj).\#\{f\text{ monic squarefree of type }\lambda\}=\prod_{j\ge1}\binom{N_q(j)}{m_j}. For each degree, choose the required distinct irreducible factors; their product determines ff.

Since Nq(j)=qj/j+Oj(qj/2)N_q(j)=q^j/j+O_j(q^{j/2}), for fixed nn this count is qn/zλ+On(qn−1)q^n/z_\lambda+O_n(q^{n-1}) as q→∞q\to\infty. Dividing by qnq^n gives the permutation probability in the limit. If repeated factors are allowed and their degrees are counted with multiplicity, the exact count instead uses ∏j(Nq(j)+mj−1mj)\prod_j\binom{N_q(j)+m_j-1}{m_j}.

References 2

Example

The three squarefree cubic types have counts typecountlimiting proportion3(q3−q)/31/32+1q(q2−q)/21/21+1+1(q3)1/6\begin{array}{c|c|c}\text{type}&\text{count}&\text{limiting proportion}\\\hline 3&(q^3-q)/3&1/3\\2+1&q(q^2-q)/2&1/2\\1+1+1&\binom q3&1/6\end{array} Their sum is q3−q2q^3-q^2, the number of squarefree monic cubics.

Over F2\mathbb F_2, the respective counts are 2,2,02,2,0. Thus the limiting proportions are not exact at a fixed small field. The lack of three distinct elements already excludes the third type.

References 1

Short intervals

Fix a monic f∈Fq[x]f\in\mathbb F_q[x] of degree nn, and let I(f,m)={f+h:h∈Fq[x], deg⁡h≤m},m<n.I(f,m)=\{f+h:h\in\mathbb F_q[x],\ \deg h\le m\},\qquad m<n. These qm+1q^{m+1} polynomials share their coefficients of degrees greater than mm.

Theorem

For 3≤m<n3\le m<n and any partition λ\lambda of nn, Bank, Bary-Soroker, and Rosenzweig prove #{g∈I(f,m):λg=λ}=qm+1zλ+On(qm+1/2).\#\{g\in I(f,m):\lambda_g=\lambda\}=\frac{q^{m+1}}{z_\lambda}+O_n(q^{m+1/2}). Here factor degrees are counted with multiplicity. The bound is uniform in q,f,m,λq,f,m,\lambda for fixed nn.

The same estimate holds for m=1m=1 if the characteristic pp does not divide n(n−1)n(n-1), and for m=2m=2 if p≠2p\ne2 or deg⁡f′>1\deg f'>1.

References 1

Monodromy and specialization

In a parameterized family, first compute the Galois group over the function field of the parameters. If the geometric group is SnS_n, suitable finite-field point-counting estimates distribute the Frobenius classes according to their sizes in SnS_n. A class with cycle type λ\lambda then contributes the proportion 1/zλ1/z_\lambda.

This group belongs to the whole family. A particular polynomial over Fq\mathbb F_q has a splitting field that is a finite field, whose Galois group is cyclic. Its Frobenius element contributes one cycle type to the family count. There is no claim that this individual polynomial has Galois group SnS_n over Fq\mathbb F_q.

References 1

Restricted coefficient families

Entin gives a quantitative method for counting factorization types in restricted sets of specializations over large finite fields. Its usefulness depends on both the family's monodromy and an estimate measuring the restriction on the parameter set.

For example, coefficients uniform in the set of squares require additional arguments: the general error estimate need not give a useful bound. Bary-Soroker and Shmueli prove the irreducibility proportion 1/n+On(q−1/2)1/n+O_n(q^{-1/2}) in that model as q→∞q\to\infty. See square coefficients for the precise probability model.

References 2

Questions

Research directionFinite fields

How does the error depend on the degree and the coefficient restrictions?

Scope. Families over Fq\mathbb F_q in which the degree, field size, or number of free coefficients varies.

The short-interval theorem above fixes the degree when taking the large-field limit. For a different regime, one must control the degree dependence of the error and compute the relevant monodromy. Establishing a limit for one family does not give a uniform theorem for all coefficient restrictions.

References 2
Discuss this question →

Related topics

References

  1. Prime polynomials in short intervals and in arithmetic progressions

    Bank, Efrat and Bary-Soroker, Lior and Rosenzweig, Lior. Duke Mathematical Journal, 164(2), 277–295, 2015.

    Read the source
  2. The distribution of polynomials over finite fields

    Cohen, Stephen D. Acta Arithmetica, 17(3), 255–271, 1970.

    Read the source
  3. Finite Fields

    Lidl, Rudolf and Niederreiter, Harald. Edition 2. Cambridge University Press, Encyclopedia of Mathematics and its Applications, vol. 20, 1997.

    Read the source
  4. Factorization statistics of restricted polynomial specializations over large finite fields

    Entin, Alexei. Israel Journal of Mathematics, 242(1), 37–53, 2021.

    Read the source
  5. Irreducibility of polynomials with square coefficients over finite fields

    Bary-Soroker, Lior and Shmueli, Roy. Finite Fields and Their Applications, 109, Article 102714, 2026.

    Read the source