Overview

  • What does a generic polynomial parametrize?
  • Why is a regular realization not necessarily generic?
  • Which groups have a one-parameter generic polynomial over the rationals?
  • How does Noether’s problem enter inverse Galois theory?

The definition

Let KK be a field and P(T,x)∈K(T)[x]P(\mathbf T,x)\in K(\mathbf T)[x] a monic separable polynomial with Galois group GG. It is generic for GG over KK if, for every extension field E/KE/K, every Galois extension of EE with group GG is the splitting field of some specialization P(t,x)P(\mathbf t,x), with t∈Er\mathbf t\in E^r where the coefficients are defined.

If this property is required only for E=KE=K, the family is called KK-parametric. A regular GG-extension of K(T)K(T) makes neither assertion: it provides a family of realizations, but need not contain every GG-extension among its fibers.

References 2

Example

Assume char⁡K≠2\operatorname{char}K\ne2. Every quadratic extension of every field E/KE/K is E(a)E(\sqrt a) for a nonsquare a∈Ea\in E. Therefore x2−Tx^2-T is generic for C2C_2. Two nonsquare parameters a,ba,b define the same quadratic extension exactly when a/ba/b is a square in EE.

Square parameters give reducible fibers.

References 1

The general polynomial

Let X1,…,XnX_1,\ldots,X_n be algebraically independent. Permuting these variables gives

K(X1,…,Xn)Sn=K(e1,…,en),K(X_1,\ldots,X_n)^{S_n}=K(e_1,\ldots,e_n),

where the eie_i are elementary symmetric functions. The polynomial with roots XiX_i is therefore a generic polynomial for SnS_n:

xn−e1xn−1+e2xn−2−⋯+(−1)nen.x^n-e_1x^{n-1}+e_2x^{n-2}-\cdots+(-1)^ne_n.

To see the parametrization, let L/EL/E be an SnS_n-extension. The fixed field of a point stabilizer has degree nn. A primitive element has a degree-nn minimal polynomial whose splitting field is LL; its coefficients supply the required parameters.

References 1

One parameter over the rationals

Theorem

The nontrivial finite groups with a one-parameter generic polynomial over Q\mathbb Q are exactly C2,C3,S3C_2,C_3,S_3.

Representatives are

  • C2:x2−TC_2:\quad x^2-T;
  • C3:x3−Tx2+(T−3)x+1C_3:\quad x^3-Tx^2+(T-3)x+1;
  • S3:x3+Tx+TS_3:\quad x^3+Tx+T.

Dèbes–König–Legrand–Neftin classify the corresponding splitting fields up to a fractional linear change of parameter.

References 1

Noether’s problem

Let a finite group GG act faithfully by permuting independent variables X1,…,XmX_1,\ldots,X_m. Noether's problem asks whether the invariant field K(X1,…,Xm)GK(X_1,\ldots,X_m)^G is purely transcendental over KK. A positive answer gives a regular GG-extension over a rational function field. Over a number field, Hilbert irreducibility then gives GG-extensions of the base field. Invariant-theoretic constructions also produce generic polynomials.

The rationality question can fail even when the group is realizable. Swan's counterexample for C47C_{47} over Q\mathbb Q concerns the invariant field for its regular permutation action. The cyclic group itself is realized by a subfield of a cyclotomic field. Failure of this construction is not a counterexample to the inverse Galois problem.

References 2

Limits of parametrization

Some groups have no generic polynomial over a given field. In particular, C8C_8 has no generic polynomial over Q\mathbb Q, regardless of the number of parameters. This does not prevent regular realizations or individual number-field realizations.

When generic polynomials exist, one can ask for the fewest parameters. This leads to essential dimension and generic dimension, which measure universal parametrization rather than the degree of one realizing polynomial.

References 2

Questions

SettledSpecialization and inverse Galois

Which nontrivial groups have a one-parameter generic polynomial over Q?

Scope. Generic polynomials over Q, with one parameter and universality over every extension field

Exactly C2,C3,S3C_2,C_3,S_3. The published classification also identifies the possible splitting fields up to a fractional linear change of parameter.

References 1
Discuss this question →

Related topics

References

  1. Generic Polynomials: Constructive Aspects of the Inverse Galois Problem

    Jensen, Christian U. and Ledet, Arne and Yui, Noriko. Mathematical Sciences Research Institute Publications 45, Cambridge University Press, 2002.

    Read the source
  2. On parametric and generic polynomials with one parameter

    Dèbes, Pierre and König, Joachim and Legrand, François and Neftin, Danny. Journal of Pure and Applied Algebra, 225(10), Article 106717, 2021.

    Read the source
  3. Invariant rational functions and a problem of Steenrod

    Swan, Richard G. Inventiones Mathematicae, 7, 148–158, 1969.

    Read the source