Overview

  • Which subgroup corresponds to the field generated by one root?
  • How do intermediate fields determine whether a root action is primitive?
  • When is the Galois group of a compositum a direct product?
  • How does extending the ground field change the Galois group?

Fixed fields

Let L/KL/K be a finite Galois extension and let G=Gal⁡(L/K)G=\operatorname{Gal}(L/K). For a subgroup H≤GH\le G, define

LH={a∈L:σ(a)=a for every σ∈H}.L^H=\{a\in L:\sigma(a)=a\text{ for every }\sigma\in H\}.

This is a field containing KK. Requiring more automorphisms to fix an element gives a smaller field: if H1⊆H2H_1\subseteq H_2, then LH2⊆LH1L^{H_2}\subseteq L^{H_1}. In the other direction, an intermediate field EE gives the subgroup Gal⁡(L/E)\operatorname{Gal}(L/E).

Fundamental theorem of Galois theory

These two constructions are inverse bijections. If E=LHE=L^H, then

[L:E]=∣H∣,[E:K]=[G:H].[L:E]=|H|,\qquad [E:K]=[G:H].

Moreover, E/KE/K is Galois if and only if HH is normal in GG. In that case restriction induces Gal⁡(E/K)≅G/H\operatorname{Gal}(E/K)\cong G/H.

The theorem depends on both normality and separability. For example, Q(23)/Q\mathbb Q(\sqrt[3]2)/\mathbb Q has degree three but trivial automorphism group; its automorphisms do not recover the ground field as their fixed field.

References 2

A root field and its stabilizer

Suppose LL is the splitting field of a separable irreducible polynomial f∈K[x]f\in K[x], and let α\alpha be a root. Its stabilizer is

H=Gα={σ∈G:σ(α)=α}=Gal⁡(L/K(α)).H=G_\alpha=\{\sigma\in G:\sigma(\alpha)=\alpha\}=\operatorname{Gal}(L/K(\alpha)).

The correspondence gives LH=K(α)L^H=K(\alpha). The roots of ff can be identified with the left cosets G/HG/H, by σH↦σ(α)\sigma H\mapsto\sigma(\alpha). Therefore

deg⁡f=[K(α):K]=[G:H],[L:K]=∣G∣.\deg f=[K(\alpha):K]=[G:H],\qquad [L:K]=|G|.

For x3−2x^3-2, the group is S3S_3, and the stabilizer of the real root is generated by complex conjugation. Its order is two; its fixed field has degree three. The field generated by one root is thus represented by a stabilizer, while the whole splitting field is represented by the identity subgroup.

References 2

Example

Example · a biquadratic extension

Let L=Q(2,3)L=\mathbb Q(\sqrt2,\sqrt3). Its four automorphisms independently change the signs of 2\sqrt2 and 3\sqrt3, so G≅C2×C2G\cong C_2\times C_2. Write ss for the sign change of 2\sqrt2, and tt for that of 3\sqrt3. The three subgroups of order two give exactly three quadratic subfields:

L⟨s⟩=Q(3),L⟨t⟩=Q(2),L⟨st⟩=Q(6).L^{\langle s\rangle}=\mathbb Q(\sqrt3),\quad L^{\langle t\rangle}=\mathbb Q(\sqrt2),\quad L^{\langle st\rangle}=\mathbb Q(\sqrt6).

The element θ=2+3\theta=\sqrt2+\sqrt3 generates LL. Its minimal polynomial is x4−10x2+1x^4-10x^2+1, with roots ±2±3\pm\sqrt2\pm\sqrt3. Each nonidentity automorphism exchanges two pairs of roots. The action is transitive, but contains neither a single transposition nor a 4-cycle.

All three subgroups are normal, so all three quadratic extensions are Galois. The correspondence also proves that there are no other proper intermediate fields.

References 2

Intermediate fields and blocks

In a transitive action of GG on a finite set Ω\Omega, a block is a nonempty subset BB such that every translate σB\sigma B either equals BB or is disjoint from BB. The action is primitive if its only blocks are singletons and Ω\Omega.

For the action on the roots of ff, let H=GαH=G_\alpha. Subgroups H⊆U⊆GH\subseteq U\subseteq G correspond to blocks containing α\alpha, by U↦UαU\mapsto U\alpha. Under the coset description Ω≅G/H\Omega\cong G/H, these are the subsets U/HU/H; their translates partition G/HG/H. Conversely, the setwise stabilizer of a block containing α\alpha is such a subgroup and acts transitively on that block.

Proposition

The action of GG on the roots of a separable irreducible polynomial is primitive if and only if the extension K(α)/KK(\alpha)/K has no proper intermediate field.

Indeed, a proper block corresponds to H⊊U⊊GH\subsetneq U\subsetneq G, hence to K⊊LU⊊K(α)K\subsetneq L^U\subsetneq K(\alpha). This proves at once that irreducible polynomials of prime degree have primitive Galois action. Composite degree does not rule out primitivity; the question is whether intermediate fields actually exist.

For the biquadratic example, fixing 2\sqrt2 partitions the roots into {2+3,2−3}\{\sqrt2+\sqrt3,\sqrt2-\sqrt3\} and its negative. These two blocks reflect the intermediate field Q(2)\mathbb Q(\sqrt2).

References 2

Composita and intersections

Let L1/KL_1/K and L2/KL_2/K be finite Galois extensions in a common algebraic closure. Their compositum L1L2L_1L_2 is the field generated by both. An automorphism of this field is determined by its restrictions to L1L_1 and L2L_2, and the restrictions must agree on the intersection.

Theorem

Restriction identifies Gal⁡(L1L2/K)\operatorname{Gal}(L_1L_2/K) with

{(σ1,σ2)∈Gal⁡(L1/K)×Gal⁡(L2/K):σ1∣L1∩L2=σ2∣L1∩L2}.\{(\sigma_1,\sigma_2)\in\operatorname{Gal}(L_1/K)\times\operatorname{Gal}(L_2/K):\sigma_1|_{L_1\cap L_2}=\sigma_2|_{L_1\cap L_2}\}.

In particular, it is the full direct product if and only if L1∩L2=KL_1\cap L_2=K. Equivalently, in this case [L1L2:K]=[L1:K][L2:K][L_1L_2:K]=[L_1:K][L_2:K].

For Q(2)\mathbb Q(\sqrt2) and Q(3)\mathbb Q(\sqrt3), the intersection is Q\mathbb Q, giving the group C2×C2C_2\times C_2 above. For larger splitting fields, determining their intersection is often the main step in a group computation. The Galois hypothesis is essential to the stated intersection criterion.

References 1

Changing the ground field

Let f∈K[x]f\in K[x] be separable, let LL be its splitting field, and let E/KE/K be a finite extension in the same algebraic closure. The splitting field over EE is LELE. Restriction gives

Gal⁡(LE/E)≅Gal⁡(L/L∩E)≤Gal⁡(L/K).\operatorname{Gal}(LE/E)\cong\operatorname{Gal}(L/L\cap E)\le\operatorname{Gal}(L/K).

Thus an extension of the ground field replaces the original group by the subgroup fixing L∩EL\cap E. The polynomial remains irreducible over EE exactly when this subgroup is transitive on the roots. If L∩E=KL\cap E=K, the whole permutation group is unchanged.

For f=x3−2f=x^3-2, adjoining a primitive cube root of unity replaces S3S_3 by A3≅C3A_3\cong C_3, which is still transitive. Adjoining the real cube root replaces S3S_3 by its order-two stabilizer, which fixes one root. In the first case the polynomial remains irreducible; in the second it factors.

The intersection formula concerns a Galois splitting field LL. It should not be replaced by an intersection calculation with only one root field.

References 2

Elements fixed by a subgroup

For any u∈Lu\in L, the distinct values σ(u)\sigma(u), with σ∈G\sigma\in G, are the roots of its minimal polynomial over KK. Consequently

mu,K(T)=∏v∈G⋅u(T−v),[K(u):K]=[G:Gu].m_{u,K}(T)=\prod_{v\in G\cdot u}(T-v),\qquad [K(u):K]=[G:G_u].

This gives a general way to find subfields: choose an expression in the roots whose stabilizer is known. The coefficients of the orbit polynomial lie in KK, because every element of GG permutes its factors. Resolvent constructions use such expressions to test which subgroup can contain the Galois group.

The discriminant is the simplest example. Assume char⁡K≠2\operatorname{char}K\ne2, write f=an∏i(x−αi)f=a_n\prod_i(x-\alpha_i), and put

δ=ann−1∏i<j(αi−αj),Δ(f)=δ2.\delta=a_n^{n-1}\prod_{i<j}(\alpha_i-\alpha_j),\qquad \Delta(f)=\delta^2.

A permutation of the roots multiplies δ\delta by its sign. Hence G⊆AnG\subseteq A_n if and only if Δ(f)\Delta(f) is a square in KK. If it is not a square, K(δ)K(\delta) is the quadratic field fixed by G∩AnG\cap A_n. This describes a quadratic subfield; it does not determine the whole group.

References 2

Applications

These correspondences explain several recurring methods. Intermediate fields reveal blocks and therefore possible imprimitive groups. Intersections determine groups of composita. Adjoining constants changes the arithmetic group to a subgroup, an essential step when comparing arithmetic and geometric Galois groups. Invariant expressions produce resolvents and distinguished subfields.

For polynomial composition, Capelli’s theorem asks whether the inner polynomial minus a root of the outer one is irreducible over that root field. For iterates, the successive equations build towers of fields, and their Galois groups act on the corresponding tree of preimages. The same field-theoretic ideas therefore continue beyond a single action on finitely many roots.

References 2

Related topics

References

  1. Fields and Galois Theory

    Milne, James S. Kea Books, 2022.

    Author’s book page
  2. The Galois correspondence

    Conrad, Keith. Author-hosted expository notes.

    Read the source
  3. The Galois correspondence at work

    Conrad, Keith. Author-hosted expository notes.

    Read the source
  4. An irreducible that factors modulo all primes

    Conrad, Keith. Author-hosted expository note.

    Read the source
  5. Permutation Groups

    Dixon, John D. and Mortimer, Brian. Graduate Texts in Mathematics 163, Springer, 1996.

    Read the source
  6. Galois Theory

    Cox, David A. Edition 2. John Wiley & Sons, 2012.

    Read the source
  7. Irreducibility of the iterates of a quadratic polynomial over a field

    Ayad, Mohamed and McQuillan, Donald L. Acta Arithmetica, 93(1), 87–97, 2000.

    Read the source
  8. Galois representations from pre-image trees: an arboreal survey

    Jones, Rafe. Publications mathématiques de Besançon. Algèbre et théorie des nombres, 107–136, 2013.

    Read the source