Overview

  • When does a square discriminant imply G βŠ† Aβ‚™?
  • How do polynomial and number-field discriminants differ?
  • How does the discriminant complete a proof that G = Sβ‚™?

Definition

For f(x)=an∏i=1n(xβˆ’Ξ±i)f(x)=a_n\prod_{i=1}^n(x-\alpha_i) of degree nβ‰₯1n\ge1, the polynomial discriminant is

Ξ”(f)=an2nβˆ’2∏i<j(Ξ±iβˆ’Ξ±j)2=(βˆ’1)n(nβˆ’1)/2anβˆ’1Res⁑(f,fβ€²).\Delta(f)=a_n^{2n-2}\prod_{i\lt j}(\alpha_i-\alpha_j)^2=(-1)^{n(n-1)/2}a_n^{-1}\operatorname{Res}(f,f').

It is nonzero exactly when the roots are distinct. The resultant formula computes it from coefficients without computing the roots. Multiplying ff by a nonzero scalar changes its discriminant by an even power, so its square class is unchanged.

References 1

The discriminant criterion

Theorem Β· discriminant criterion

If f∈K[x]f\in K[x] is separable and char⁑Kβ‰ 2\operatorname{char}K\ne2, then

Gal⁑(f/K)βŠ†AnβŸΊΞ”(f)∈KΓ—2.\operatorname{Gal}(f/K)\subseteq A_n\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad\Delta(f)\in K^{\times2}.

Proof

Set D=annβˆ’1∏i<j(Ξ±iβˆ’Ξ±j)D=a_n^{n-1}\prod_{i\lt j}(\alpha_i-\alpha_j), so D2=Ξ”(f)D^2=\Delta(f). An automorphism Οƒ\sigma sends DD to sgn⁑(Οƒ)D\operatorname{sgn}(\sigma)D. Thus all automorphisms are even exactly when DD belongs to the ground field. Conversely, if D2=b2D^2=b^2 with b∈Kb\in K, then D=Β±bD=\pm b, so D∈KD\in K. Characteristic two is excluded because the signs coincide.

If the group is not contained in AnA_n, the quadratic field K(Ξ”(f))K(\sqrt{\Delta(f)}) is the fixed field of the kernel of the sign character.

References 2

Cubics

Example

A separable irreducible cubic has a transitive subgroup of S3S_3, hence group A3A_3 or S3S_3. For x3+ax+bx^3+ax+b, the discriminant is βˆ’4a3βˆ’27b2-4a^3-27b^2. Therefore

fΞ”(f)Gal⁑(f/Q)x3βˆ’xβˆ’1βˆ’23S3x3βˆ’3xβˆ’181C3\begin{array}{c|c|c} f & \Delta(f) & \operatorname{Gal}(f/\mathbb Q)\\ \hline x^3-x-1&-23&S_3\\ x^3-3x-1&81&C_3\end{array}

The rational-root test proves both polynomials irreducible: neither 11 nor βˆ’1-1 is a root. Irreducibility is required to apply the cubic classification.

References 1

Quartic examples

The polynomial x4+1x^4+1 is irreducible over Q\mathbb Q, since replacing xx by x+1x+1 makes it Eisenstein at 22. Its discriminant is 256256, but its splitting field is Q(ΞΆ8)\mathbb Q(\zeta_8), whose group is (Z/8Z)×≃C2Γ—C2(\mathbb Z/8\mathbb Z)^\times\simeq C_2\times C_2, strictly smaller than A4A_4.

For a nonsquare example, x4βˆ’2x^4-2 is Eisenstein at 22 and has nonsquare discriminant βˆ’2048-2048. Its splitting field is Q(24,i)\mathbb Q(\sqrt[4]{2},i), of degree eight: the real field Q(24)\mathbb Q(\sqrt[4]{2}) has degree four and does not contain ii. The group is dihedral of order eight, not S4S_4.

Remark

If AnβŠ†GA_n\subseteq G is known, a square discriminant gives G=AnG=A_n, and a nonsquare discriminant gives G=SnG=S_n.

References 2

Polynomial and field discriminants

If ff is the monic minimal polynomial of an algebraic integer Ξ±\alpha, and K=Q(Ξ±)K=\mathbb Q(\alpha), then

Ξ”(f)=disc⁑(K) [OK:Z[Ξ±]]2.\Delta(f)=\operatorname{disc}(K)\,[\mathcal O_K:\mathbb Z[\alpha]]^2.

The two discriminants have the same square class, but can have different prime divisors. A prime dividing Ξ”(f)\Delta(f) may come from the index rather than ramification in KK.

For f=x2βˆ’5f=x^2-5, the polynomial discriminant is 2020, whereas disc⁑(Q(5))=5\operatorname{disc}(\mathbb Q(\sqrt5))=5. Reduction modulo 22 is repeated, although 22 is unramified in the quadratic field. The integral generator (1+5)/2(1+\sqrt5)/2, with polynomial x2βˆ’xβˆ’1x^2-x-1, removes this index obstruction.

Over Q\mathbb Q, complex conjugation also determines the sign of the discriminant: with rr nonreal conjugate pairs it has type 2r1nβˆ’2r2^r1^{n-2r}, and sgn⁑Δ(f)=(βˆ’1)r\operatorname{sgn}\Delta(f)=(-1)^r.

References 2

Double discriminants

For nβ‰₯2n\ge2, 0≀k≀n0\le k\le n, and the generic polynomial f=βˆ‘i=0naixif=\sum_{i=0}^n a_ix^i, put DDn,k=disc⁑ak(disc⁑xf)DD_{n,k}=\operatorname{disc}_{a_k}(\operatorname{disc}_x f). In their 2025 preprint, Anderson and collaborators give a factorization

DDn,k=cn,kR0RnAn,k3Bn,k2.DD_{n,k}=c_{n,k}R_0R_nA_{n,k}^{3}B_{n,k}^{2}.

Here R0=a0R_0=a_0 only when k=1k=1, and Rn=anR_n=a_n only when k=nβˆ’1k=n-1; otherwise these factors are 11. The other factors are explicit polynomials. The cube and square describe the loci with a triple root and two double roots, respectively. These factors may be constant in small degrees.

References 1

Root sets

Fix NβŠ†Z\mathcal N\subseteq\mathbb Z containing a nonzero element. Let M(N)M(\mathcal N) be the closure of the complex roots of polynomials with coefficients in N\mathcal N and nonzero constant term. Hokken proves that restricting to square discriminants gives the same closure if N\mathcal N is closed under negation, closed under multiplication, or contains {Β±1}\{\pm1\}.

The general statement permits discriminant zero. For Littlewood polynomials, the approximating polynomials can be separable and reciprocal, with square discriminant. Their Galois groups therefore consist of even permutations. The construction uses Rouché’s theorem; it does not establish irreducibility.

References 1

Questions

SettledGalois group

When can a discriminant determine the full Galois group?

Scope. Characteristic different from 2; separable irreducible cubics, or groups already known to contain AnA_n.

It determines the group for irreducible cubics, and whenever an independent argument has proved AnβŠ†GA_n\subseteq G. In general it determines only whether GβŠ†AnG\subseteq A_n.

References 2
Discuss this question β†’
OpenGalois group

Does a square discriminant preserve the root-set closure for every coefficient set?

Scope. Sets of integer coefficients containing a nonzero element; nonzero constant term; the degree varies.

Is Mβ–‘(N)=M(N)M^{\square}(\mathcal N)=M(\mathcal N) for every such N\mathcal N? The source asks this after Theorem 1. Its general definition allows zero discriminant; the stronger question with nonzero square discriminant requires a separate argument.

References 1
Discuss this question β†’
OpenGalois group

Which primes divide the content of a double discriminant?

Scope. The generic degree-n polynomial; 1≀k≀nβˆ’1; c_n,k is the positive gcd of the integer coefficients of DD_n,k.

The cited conjecture predicts that the prime divisors of cn,kc_{n,k} are exactly those of 2gcd⁑(n,k)2\gcd(n,k). Section 4 gives finer conjectures about their valuations. This concerns the universal discriminant polynomial, not the discriminant of one specialization.

References 1
Discuss this question β†’

Related topics

References

  1. Fields and Galois Theory

    Milne, James S. Kea Books, 2022.

    Author’s book page
  2. Galois groups of cubics and quartics (not in characteristic 2)

    Conrad, Keith. Author-hosted expository note.

    Read the source
  3. Galois Theory

    Cox, David A. Edition 2. John Wiley & Sons, 2012.

    Read the source
  4. Algebraic Number Theory

    Neukirch, JΓΌrgen. Springer, Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften, vol. 322, 1999.

    Read the source
  5. The structure of the double discriminant

    Anderson, Theresa C. and Asarhasa, Ufuoma V. and Bertelli, Adam and Gundlach, Fabian and O’Dorney, Evan M. arXiv, 2025.

    Read the source
  6. Topology of zero sets of polynomials with square discriminant

    Hokken, David. Comptes Rendus. MathΓ©matique, 364, 101–106, 2026.

    Read the source