Overview
- When does a square discriminant imply G β Aβ?
- How do polynomial and number-field discriminants differ?
- How does the discriminant complete a proof that G = Sβ?
Definition
For of degree , the polynomial discriminant is
It is nonzero exactly when the roots are distinct. The resultant formula computes it from coefficients without computing the roots. Multiplying by a nonzero scalar changes its discriminant by an even power, so its square class is unchanged.
References 1
- Milne2022 Β· Chapter 4 and its appendix on resultantsAuthorβs book page
The discriminant criterion
Theorem Β· discriminant criterion
If is separable and , then
Proof
Set , so . An automorphism sends to . Thus all automorphisms are even exactly when belongs to the ground field. Conversely, if with , then , so . Characteristic two is excluded because the signs coincide.
If the group is not contained in , the quadratic field is the fixed field of the kernel of the sign character.
References 2
- ConradCubicQuartic Β· Theorem 1.3Source
- Milne2022 Β· Chapter 4, βWhen is G_f contained in A_n?βAuthorβs book page
Cubics
Example
A separable irreducible cubic has a transitive subgroup of , hence group or . For , the discriminant is . Therefore
The rational-root test proves both polynomials irreducible: neither nor is a root. Irreducibility is required to apply the cubic classification.
References 1
- ConradCubicQuartic Β· Theorem 2.1 and Example 2.2Source
Quartic examples
The polynomial is irreducible over , since replacing by makes it Eisenstein at . Its discriminant is , but its splitting field is , whose group is , strictly smaller than .
For a nonsquare example, is Eisenstein at and has nonsquare discriminant . Its splitting field is , of degree eight: the real field has degree four and does not contain . The group is dihedral of order eight, not .
Remark
If is known, a square discriminant gives , and a nonsquare discriminant gives .
References 2
- Cox2012Cyclotomic and radical extensions; discriminant interpretation.Source
- ConradCubicQuartic Β· Section 3Source
Polynomial and field discriminants
If is the monic minimal polynomial of an algebraic integer , and , then
The two discriminants have the same square class, but can have different prime divisors. A prime dividing may come from the index rather than ramification in .
For , the polynomial discriminant is , whereas . Reduction modulo is repeated, although is unramified in the quadratic field. The integral generator , with polynomial , removes this index obstruction.
Over , complex conjugation also determines the sign of the discriminant: with nonreal conjugate pairs it has type , and .
References 2
- Neukirch1999Discriminants of orders, indices, and ramification.Source
- ConradCubicQuartic Β· Remark 3.11 and the discussion of real rootsSource
Double discriminants
For , , and the generic polynomial , put . In their 2025 preprint, Anderson and collaborators give a factorization
Here only when , and only when ; otherwise these factors are . The other factors are explicit polynomials. The cube and square describe the loci with a triple root and two double roots, respectively. These factors may be constant in small degrees.
References 1
- AndersonEtAl2025DoubleDiscriminant Β· Theorem 1.1, Remark 1.2, and Theorems 3.1, 3.4 and 3.11 (arXiv v2)Source
Root sets
Fix containing a nonzero element. Let be the closure of the complex roots of polynomials with coefficients in and nonzero constant term. Hokken proves that restricting to square discriminants gives the same closure if is closed under negation, closed under multiplication, or contains .
The general statement permits discriminant zero. For Littlewood polynomials, the approximating polynomials can be separable and reciprocal, with square discriminant. Their Galois groups therefore consist of even permutations. The construction uses RouchΓ©βs theorem; it does not establish irreducibility.
References 1
- Hokken2026ZeroTopology Β· Theorem 1; Lemmas 3β4; Corollary 5Source
Questions
When can a discriminant determine the full Galois group?
Scope. Characteristic different from 2; separable irreducible cubics, or groups already known to contain .
It determines the group for irreducible cubics, and whenever an independent argument has proved . In general it determines only whether .
References 2
- ConradCubicQuartic Β· Theorems 1.3 and 2.1Source
- Milne2022 Β· Corollary 4.2(b), p. 58; Example 4.7, p. 60 (published book)Authorβs book page
Does a square discriminant preserve the root-set closure for every coefficient set?
Scope. Sets of integer coefficients containing a nonzero element; nonzero constant term; the degree varies.
Is for every such ? The source asks this after Theorem 1. Its general definition allows zero discriminant; the stronger question with nonzero square discriminant requires a separate argument.
References 1
- Hokken2026ZeroTopology Β· Question following Theorem 1; Corollary 5Source
Which primes divide the content of a double discriminant?
Scope. The generic degree-n polynomial; 1β€kβ€nβ1; c_n,k is the positive gcd of the integer coefficients of DD_n,k.
The cited conjecture predicts that the prime divisors of are exactly those of . Section 4 gives finer conjectures about their valuations. This concerns the universal discriminant polynomial, not the discriminant of one specialization.
References 1
- AndersonEtAl2025DoubleDiscriminant Β· Conjectures 1.4 and 4.1Source
Related topics
Connected diagrams
- How do two modular factorizations determine Sβ ? Β· Classical
- When does a reciprocal polynomial have the full signed group? Β· Classical
- Central-binomial sections: exact groups and prime reductions Β· Claimed
- Negative Laguerre parameters: a complete Galois classification Β· Published
Frobenius and factorization modulo primes
Primes not dividing the polynomial discriminant have squarefree reduction.
Applies toResolvents and subgroup tests
The cubic resolvent and the discriminant together distinguish several quartic groups.
UsesTransitivity, primitivity, and cycle criteria
Containment of A_n and an odd permutation imply equality with S_n.
Applies toRandom polynomials: models and methods
Alternating-group containment and a nonsquare discriminant require separate probability estimates.
Linked from 19 articles
- The Galois correspondence and intermediate fields
- Newton polygons and Galois groups
- Capelliβs theorem and polynomial composition
- Frobenius and factorization modulo primes
- Ramification and inertia
- Transitivity, primitivity, and cycle criteria
- Resolvents and subgroup tests
- Reciprocal polynomials
- Taylor polynomials
- Taylor polynomials and KatzβRivin questions
- Bernoulli and Euler polynomials
- Touchard polynomials
- Chromatic polynomials
- Hecke polynomials and Maedaβs conjecture
- Zero polynomials of Eisenstein series
- Random polynomials: models and methods
- Characteristic polynomials of random matrices
- Twisted reciprocity and square discriminants
- Gleason and Misiurewicz polynomials
References
- Fields and Galois Theory
Milne, James S. Kea Books, 2022.
Authorβs book page - Galois groups of cubics and quartics (not in characteristic 2)
Conrad, Keith. Author-hosted expository note.
Read the source - Galois Theory
Cox, David A. Edition 2. John Wiley & Sons, 2012.
Read the source - Algebraic Number Theory
Neukirch, JΓΌrgen. Springer, Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften, vol. 322, 1999.
Read the source - The structure of the double discriminant
Anderson, Theresa C. and Asarhasa, Ufuoma V. and Bertelli, Adam and Gundlach, Fabian and OβDorney, Evan M. arXiv, 2025.
Read the source - Topology of zero sets of polynomials with square discriminant
Hokken, David. Comptes Rendus. MathΓ©matique, 364, 101β106, 2026.
Read the source
Comments
Any comments are welcome. Comments appear after the site owner approves them. Privacy policy.