Overview

  • How does the substitution y = x + b/x describe the root pairs?
  • What is the discriminant in terms of the trace polynomial?
  • How does this identity enter counts of exceptional groups?

The trace substitution

Fix an integer b≠0b\ne0. A rational polynomial FF of degree 2m2m is bb-reciprocal if

F(x)=x2mbmF(b/x).F(x)=\frac{x^{2m}}{b^m}F(b/x).

Its nonzero roots are paired by α↦b/α\alpha\mapsto b/\alpha. A fixed point α2=b\alpha^2=b is a repeated root: the corresponding quadratic x2−2αx+bx^2-2\alpha x+b equals (x−α)2(x-\alpha)^2. For separable FF, the group therefore acts on distinct pairs and embeds in Wm=C2≀SmW_m=C_2\wr S_m.

The invariant variable is y=x+b/xy=x+b/x, and F(x)=xmQ(x+b/x)F(x)=x^mQ(x+b/x) for a degree-mm polynomial QQ. Each trace root yiy_i corresponds to the quadratic x2−yix+bx^2-y_ix+b.

References 1

The discriminant formula

Identity

If F(x)=xmQ(x+b/x)F(x)=x^mQ(x+b/x), then

disc⁡(F)=bm(m−1)Q(2b)Q(−2b)disc⁡(Q)2.\operatorname{disc}(F)=b^{m(m-1)}Q(2\sqrt b)Q(-2\sqrt b)\operatorname{disc}(Q)^2.

Proof

Write Q(y)=a∏i=1m(y−yi)Q(y)=a\prod_{i=1}^{m}(y-y_i). The quadratic x2−yix+bx^2-y_ix+b has discriminant yi2−4by_i^2-4b. For i≠ji\ne j, the two quadratics have resultant b(yi−yj)2b(y_i-y_j)^2. Indeed, evaluating their difference at the two roots of the first quadratic gives a product of b(yi−yj)2b(y_i-y_j)^2. The discriminant product formula gives

a4m−2∏i(yi2−4b) bm(m−1)∏i<j(yi−yj)4,a^{4m-2}\prod_i(y_i^2-4b)\,b^{m(m-1)}\prod_{i<j}(y_i-y_j)^4,

which is the right-hand side of the identity.

For a separable polynomial, since m(m−1)m(m-1) is even, its discriminant has the square class of Q(2b)Q(−2b)Q(2\sqrt b)Q(-2\sqrt b). The product is rational even when b∉Q\sqrt b\notin\mathbb Q.

References 1

Example

Take Q(y)=y2−y−1Q(y)=y^2-y-1. Then

F(x)=x2Q(x+2/x)=x4−x3+3x2−2x+4.F(x)=x^2Q(x+2/x)=x^4-x^3+3x^2-2x+4.

Here disc⁡(Q)=5\operatorname{disc}(Q)=5, and

Q(22)Q(−22)=(7−22)(7+22)=41.Q(2\sqrt2)Q(-2\sqrt2)=(7-2\sqrt2)(7+2\sqrt2)=41.

Thus disc⁡(F)=22⋅41⋅52=4100\operatorname{disc}(F)=2^2\cdot41\cdot5^2=4100 is nonsquare. The Galois group contains an odd permutation, so it is not contained in A4A_4. This leaves the exact subgroup of W2W_2 undetermined.

Exceptional groups at fixed degree

Fix integers m≥4m\ge4 and b≠0b\ne0. For an integer bb-reciprocal polynomial F(x)=∑i=02maixiF(x)=\sum_{i=0}^{2m}a_ix^i of degree 2m2m, use the weighted Euclidean height

Ht⁡b(F)=(∑i=02m∣b∣iai2)1/2.\operatorname{Ht}_b(F)=\left(\sum_{i=0}^{2m}|b|^i a_i^2\right)^{1/2}.

Let Em,b(H)\mathcal E_{m,b}(H) count separable such polynomials of height at most HH whose Galois group is smaller than WmW_m, and let Em,bmonic(H)\mathcal E^{\mathrm{monic}}_{m,b}(H) count the monic subset.

Preprint theorem · O’Dorney

Em,b(H)=cm,bHmlog⁡H+Om,b(Hm),Em,bmonic(H)=cm,bmonicHm−1log⁡H+Om,b(Hm−1).\begin{aligned}\mathcal E_{m,b}(H)&=c_{m,b}H^m\log H+O_{m,b}(H^m),\\\mathcal E^{\mathrm{monic}}_{m,b}(H)&=c^{\mathrm{monic}}_{m,b}H^{m-1}\log H+O_{m,b}(H^{m-1}).\end{aligned}

The constants are explicit and positive. The main term comes from G1=Wm∩A2mG_1=W_m\cap A_{2m}; all other exceptional groups together contribute at most the stated error terms.

The discriminant formula reduces the even-permutation condition to a square-value condition on the trace polynomial. Anderson–Bertelli–O’Dorney treat the untwisted case b=1b=1 in the published paper.

References 2

Related topics

References

  1. Galois groups of twisted reciprocal polynomials: a uniform asymptotic

    O'Dorney, Evan M. arXiv preprint, 2026.

    Read the source
  2. Galois Theory

    Cox, David A. Edition 2. John Wiley & Sons, 2012.

    Read the source
  3. Galois groups of reciprocal polynomials and the van der Waerden-Bhargava theorem

    Anderson, Theresa C. and Bertelli, Adam and O'Dorney, Evan M. Algebra & Number Theory, 20(3), 603–628, 2026.

    Read the source