Overview

  • When does ∑j=0nxj/j!\sum_{j=0}^n x^j/j! have group AnA_n or SnS_n?
  • How do its coefficient valuations prove irreducibility?
  • When is 1+x+⋯+xn1+x+\cdots+x^n irreducible?

Definition

For F(x)=∑j≥0ajxj∈Q[[x]]F(x)=\sum_{j\ge0}a_jx^j\in\mathbb Q[[x]], let F≤n=∑j=0najxjF_{\le n}=\sum_{j=0}^n a_jx^j. Its degree is nn only when an≠0a_n\ne0. Multiplying by a nonzero rational scalar clears denominators without changing the roots or splitting field. Analytic convergence and the limiting location of complex roots provide useful structure, but do not alone prove irreducibility over Q\mathbb Q.

Katz and Rivin ask about the frequencies of Galois groups in such sequences. Rabarison, Pazuki, and Molin give a later survey and extend the experimental viewpoint to Padé approximants. Truncations and rational approximants require distinct definitions and normalizations.

References 2

Schur’s theorem

Theorem (Schur)

For every n≥2n\ge2, Tn(x)=∑j=0nxj/j!T_n(x)=\sum_{j=0}^n x^j/j! is irreducible over Q\mathbb Q, and

Gal⁡(Tn/Q)={An,4∣n,Sn,4∤n.\operatorname{Gal}(T_n/\mathbb Q)=\begin{cases}A_n,&4\mid n,\\S_n,&4\nmid n.\end{cases}

The proof excludes every proper factor degree, proves containment of AnA_n, and computes the discriminant square class. Coleman’s Newton-polygon proof illustrates the use of factorial valuations.

References 2

Discriminant

Set Pn=n!TnP_n=n!T_n, which is monic. Since Pn′=Pn−xnP_n'=P_n-x^n, each root rr satisfies Pn′(r)=−rnP_n'(r)=-r^n. The constant term is n!n!, so multiplying these identities over the roots gives

disc⁡(Pn)=(−1)n(n−1)/2(n!)n.\operatorname{disc}(P_n)=(-1)^{n(n-1)/2}(n!)^n.

For even nn, this is a rational square exactly when 4∣n4\mid n: its magnitude is already a square and its sign decides the issue. For odd n≥3n\ge3, a prime between n/2n/2 and nn occurs exactly once in n!n!, so the discriminant is a nonsquare. This step determines the group only after AnA_n-containment has been proved.

References 1
  • Coleman1987The discriminant square test; the resultant computation is included explicitly.Source

Example

Example

P6=x6+6x5+30x4+120x3+360x2+720x+720.P_6=x^6+6x^5+30x^4+120x^3+360x^2+720x+720.

At 22, its lower Newton polygon has vertices (0,4),(4,1),(6,0)(0,4),(4,1),(6,0); a proper rational factor can therefore have only degree 22 or 44. At 33, the polygon is the segment from (0,2)(0,2) to (6,0)(6,0), so a proper factor can have only degree 33. The allowed degrees are disjoint, so the polynomial is irreducible.

References 1
  • Coleman1987The Newton-polygon mechanism; the displayed degree-six coefficients and vertices are checked directly.Source

Geometric truncations

The degree-n truncation of (1−x)−1(1-x)^{-1} is

1+x+⋯+xn=∏d∣n+1d>1Φd(x).1+x+\cdots+x^n=\prod_{\substack{d\mid n+1\\d>1}}\Phi_d(x).

For n≥1n\ge1, it is irreducible exactly when n+1n+1 is prime; its splitting field is Q(ζn+1)\mathbb Q(\zeta_{n+1}), with group (Z/(n+1)Z)×(\mathbb Z/(n+1)\mathbb Z)^\times. The groups are therefore abelian.

In other truncation families, parity, vanishing coefficients, or rational-function identities may force factors. The remaining factors can be studied through uniform valuation patterns, specialization theorems, or permutation-group arguments. Numerical frequencies alone do not establish a limit.

References 2

Katz–Rivin questions

Recent preprints address the Galois-group frequencies of Taylor sections, including arbitrary symmetric-degree prescriptions and arithmetic results for binomial and Catalan families. See Taylor polynomials and Katz–Rivin questions for precise statements, methods, and remaining questions.

References 1

Shifted exponential polynomials

For a fixed positive integer aa, define

Fn,a(x)=∑j=0nxj(a+j)!.F_{n,a}(x)=\sum_{j=0}^n\frac{x^j}{(a+j)!}.

Weinbaum’s 2026 preprint claims that the degrees nn for which Gal⁡(Fn,a/Q)=Sn\operatorname{Gal}(F_{n,a}/\mathbb Q)=S_n have natural density one. The argument combines factor-degree bounds, Newton polygons, and a separate estimate for square discriminants. This addresses the positive shifts considered by Katz and Rivin. The parameter aa is fixed; the statement allows exceptional degrees.

For a=0a=0, Schur’s theorem instead gives alternating group at every degree divisible by four.

References 2

Questions

Research directionPolynomial families

When does a truncation family have a limiting Galois-group frequency?

Scope. A specified rational power series, a stated normalization, and n tending to infinity.

Katz–Rivin ask for a structural description of series with convergent Galois-group frequencies. Nguyen-Dang’s version 3 claims counterexamples to universal convergence, while this classification question remains open. The separate article distinguishes arbitrary constructions from arithmetic families.

References 2
Discuss this question →
ClaimedPolynomial families

Do positive shifts of the exponential series have symmetric group in density one?

Scope. Each fixed integer a≥1a\ge1; the polynomials Fn,aF_{n,a} over Q\mathbb Q, as n→∞n\to\infty.

Weinbaum’s preprint claims an affirmative answer. This is a density statement for each fixed shift, not an all-degree result.

References 1
Discuss this question →

Related topics

References

  1. Speculations in Galois Theory

    Katz, Nicholas M. and Rivin, Igor. Laumon volume (online contribution).

    Read the source
  2. Exponentielle tronquée et autres contes galoisiens

    Rabarison, Patrick and Pazuki, Fabien and Molin, Pascal. Publications mathématiques de Besançon. Algèbre et théorie des nombres, 105–117, 2024.

    Read the source
  3. Gleichungen ohne Affekt

    Schur, Issai. Sitzungsberichte der Preußischen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Physikalisch-Mathematische Klasse, 443–449, 1930.

    Historical citation verification
  4. On the Galois groups of the exponential Taylor polynomials

    Coleman, Robert F. L'Enseignement Mathématique, 33, 183–189, 1987.

    Read the source
  5. Galois Theory

    Cox, David A. Edition 2. John Wiley & Sons, 2012.

    Read the source
  6. Galois groups of Taylor polynomials: prescriptions and arithmetic families

    Nguyen-Dang, Khai-Hoan. Hexagon preprint, 2026.

    Read the source
  7. Galois Groups of Shifted Exponential Polynomials

    Weinbaum, Shachar. arXiv:2610.26873v2, 2026.

    Read the source