Overview

  • How is the zero polynomial φk\varphi_k defined?
  • For which weights is irreducibility proved?
  • Can two distinct weights give zero polynomials with a common root?

Definition

For even k≥4k\ge4, let EkE_k be the normalized Eisenstein series for SL2(Z)\mathrm{SL}_2(\mathbb Z). Let

φk(X)=∏τ∈H/SL2(Z)Ek(τ)=0, j(τ)≠0,1728(X−j(τ)),\varphi_k(X)=\prod_{\substack{\tau\in\mathbb H/\mathrm{SL}_2(\mathbb Z)\\E_k(\tau)=0,\ j(\tau)\ne0,1728}}(X-j(\tau)),

with zeros counted with multiplicity. This polynomial lies in Q[X]\mathbb Q[X]. The exclusions remove the elliptic zeros. When φk=1\varphi_k=1, there is no irreducibility assertion; the conjecture concerns positive degree.

References 2

Known cases

González proves that φ12⋅2ℓ\varphi_{12\cdot2^\ell} is irreducible for every ℓ≥0\ell\ge0. His proof uses a recurrence for Eisenstein series to control coefficient valuations, then applies Dumas’ criterion.

For instance,

φ16(X)=X−34560003617.\varphi_{16}(X)=X-\frac{3456000}{3617}.

Its linearity settles this individual case immediately.

References 1

Related families

Hecke polynomials record eigenvalues of Hecke operators. Kaneko–Zagier polynomials instead lift supersingular polynomials. The zero polynomials here record the zeros of the Eisenstein series itself.

A related coefficient-valuation conjecture of González is reported proved by Chiriac–Jorza in their 2026 preprint. This concerns coefficient valuations, not irreducibility of every φk\varphi_k.

References 2

Questions

OpenPolynomial families

Are all nonconstant Eisenstein zero polynomials irreducible?

Scope. Even k≥4 with deg(φ_k)>0; ground field Q.

The conjecture predicts irreducibility of φk\varphi_k. González proves it for k=12⋅2ℓk=12\cdot2^\ell, ℓ≥0\ell\ge0. The general assertion is recorded as conjectural in that source.

References 1
Discuss this question →
OpenPolynomial families

Do Eisenstein zero polynomials have full symmetric group?

Scope. Even k≥4 with d=deg(φ_k)>0; ground field Q.

Mahlburg–Ono record the stronger prediction Gal⁡(φk/Q)=Sd\operatorname{Gal}(\varphi_k/\mathbb Q)=S_d. The known irreducibility theorem alone does not determine this group.

References 2
Discuss this question →
OpenPolynomial families

Can two distinct Eisenstein zero polynomials share a root?

Scope. Distinct even weights k, ℓ≥4; the polynomials φ_k and φ_ℓ defined above.

Griffin and collaborators conjecture gcd⁡(φk,φℓ)=1\gcd(\varphi_k,\varphi_\ell)=1. Equivalently, the two Eisenstein series have no common non-elliptic zero modulo SL2(Z)\mathrm{SL}_2(\mathbb Z). Their Conjecture 3.1 is weaker than the general irreducibility conjecture and is stated separately.

References 1
Discuss this question →

Related topics

References

  1. Irreducibility of the zero polynomials of Eisenstein series

    González, Oscar E. Archiv der Mathematik, 119, 351–358, 2022.

    Read the source
  2. Arithmetic of certain hypergeometric modular forms

    Mahlburg, Karl and Ono, Ken. Acta Arithmetica, 113(1), 39–55, 2004.

    Read the source
  3. Lacunary recurrences and 2-adic properties of Eisenstein series

    Chiriac, Liubomir and Jorza, Andrei. arXiv:2605.09738v2, 2026.

    Read the source
  4. Monomials of Eisenstein series

    Griffin, Trevor and Kenshur, Nathan and Price, Abigail and Vandenberg-Daves, Bradshaw and Xue, Hui and Zhu, Daozhou. Journal of Number Theory, 219, 445–459, 2021.

    Read the source