Overview

  • Which four Jacobi families occur?
  • What is proved about their irreducibility and Galois groups?
  • What does the 2026 preprint claim?

Four Jacobi families

With the standard Jacobi convention, define

Jn(α,β)(x)=∑j=0n(n+αn−j)(n+α+β+jj)xj.J_n^{(\alpha,\beta)}(x)=\sum_{j=0}^n\binom{n+\alpha}{n-j}\binom{n+\alpha+\beta+j}{j}x^j.

This equals Pn(α,β)(1+2x)P_n^{(\alpha,\beta)}(1+2x). For α∈{−1/3,1/3}\alpha\in\{-1/3,1/3\}, β∈{−1/2,1/2}\beta\in\{-1/2,1/2\}, and n≥1n\ge1, rational changes of variable and nonzero scaling identify these four families with the Kaneko–Zagier polynomials after their forced elliptic factors are removed. When the modular weight plus one is prime, the latter reduce to the nontrivial part of the supersingular polynomial.

References 1

Published results

Mahlburg–Ono prove irreducibility in several infinite degree families. Cullinan–Hajir give further cases and a prime criterion for the full symmetric group under an irreducibility hypothesis. Their verification up to modular index ℓ≤109\ell\le10^9 determines the group under the assumption of irreducibility.

Cullinan–Gajek-Leonard calculate further Newton polygons and derive additional one-edge irreducibility cases.

References 3

Recent preprint

A 22 October 2026 preprint by Nguyen-Dang claims a complete proof of the Mahlburg–Ono conjecture for these four families. Its claim is recorded separately from the published partial results. The full proof has not been independently checked.

References 1

Connections and evidence

Claimed · preprint

Four Jacobi families: modular forms, symmetric groups, and Jacobians

The Kaneko–Zagier families connect modular polynomial factors to an all-degree symmetric-group claim; Zarhin’s published theorem then controls the associated hyperelliptic Jacobians.

Scope. For f=Pn(λ/3,μ/2)f=P_n^{(\lambda/3,\mu/2)} over Q\mathbb Q, n≥1n\ge1, λ,μ∈{±1}\lambda,\mu\in\{\pm1\}. The Galois assertion is a preprint claim; the Jacobian consequence requires n≥5n\ge5 and that assertion.

Four Jacobi families: modular forms, symmetric groups, and JacobiansThe Kaneko–Zagier families connect modular polynomial factors to an all-degree symmetric-group claim; Zarhin’s published theorem then controls the associated hyperelliptic Jacobians. Connection 1: Four Jacobi families: ±1/3, ±1/2 is an input to Modular polynomial factors. The four Jacobi polynomials become Kaneko–Zagier modular factors under the stated rational affine substitution and scaling. Connection 2: Four Jacobi families: ±1/3, ±1/2 leads to Irreducible with Galois group Sₙ. The preprint claims irreducibility and the full symmetric group for each of the four families in every positive degree. Preprint claim. Connection 3: Four Jacobi families: ±1/3, ±1/2 is an input to Smooth model of y² = f(x). The distinct roots of f are the finite branch points of the smooth projective model of y²=f(x). Connection 4: Irreducible with Galois group Sₙ is an input to AND. The symmetric-group input is the preprint-dependent hypothesis for this application. Connection 5: Smooth model of y² = f(x) is an input to AND. Zarhin’s argument uses the root permutation action on the Jacobian’s 2-torsion. Connection 6: Degree n ≥ 5; characteristic zero is an input to AND. The application is over Q and is restricted to n≥5. Connection 7: AND leads to Geometric endomorphism ring ℤ. For a characteristic-zero polynomial of degree at least five with group Sₙ or Aₙ, Zarhin proves that every geometric Jacobian endomorphism is integer multiplication. Connection 8: Geometric endomorphism ring ℤ leads to Absolutely simple Jacobian. A nontrivial abelian subvariety would give an idempotent in the rational endomorphism algebra, whereas End⁰=Q has only 0 and 1.Four Jacobi families: ±1/3, ±1/2 — related articleFour Jacobi families:±1/3, ±1/2Modular polynomial factors — related articleModular polynomialfactorsIrreducible with Galois group Sₙ — related articleIrreducible with Galoisgroup SₙSmooth model of y² = f(x) — related articleSmooth model of y² = f(x)Degree n ≥ 5; characteristic zero — related articleDegree n ≥ 5;characteristic zeroANDANDGeometric endomorphism ring ℤ — related articleGeometric endomorphismring ℤAbsolutely simple Jacobian — related articleAbsolutely simpleJacobianConnection 1: The four Jacobi polynomials become Kaneko–Zagier modular factors under the stated rational affine substitution and scaling.Rational affinenormalization [1]Connection 2: The preprint claims irreducibility and the full symmetric group for each of the four families in every positive degree.All n ≥ 1; preprintTheorem 1.1 [2]Connection 3: The distinct roots of f are the finite branch points of the smooth projective model of y²=f(x).Construct the doublecover [3]Connection 4: The symmetric-group input is the preprint-dependent hypothesis for this application.Large root permutationgroup [4]Connection 5: Zarhin’s argument uses the root permutation action on the Jacobian’s 2-torsion.Its Jacobian and2-torsion [5]Connection 6: The application is over Q and is restricted to n≥5.Required degree andfield [6]Connection 7: For a characteristic-zero polynomial of degree at least five with group Sₙ or Aₙ, Zarhin proves that every geometric Jacobian endomorphism is integer multiplication.Zarhin: Theorem 2.1 [7]Connection 8: A nontrivial abelian subvariety would give an idempotent in the rational endomorphism algebra, whereas End⁰=Q has only 0 and 1.No nontrivial idempotent[8]
Linked nodes open articles; numbered connections open the evidence below.Open full-size diagram

deduction or information flow preprint claimAND joint hypotheses

Let f=Pn(λ/3,μ/2)f=P_n^{(\lambda/3,\mu/2)}, with n≥1n\ge1 and λ,μ∈{±1}\lambda,\mu\in\{\pm1\}. Theorem 1.1 of the 2026 Jacobi preprint claims that every such polynomial is irreducible over Q\mathbb Q and has group SnS_n.

The published modular identification is exact. Put ℓ=12n+6+2λ+3μ\ell=12n+6+2\lambda+3\mu. The corresponding Kaneko–Zagier factor is

F~ℓ−1(Y)=1728nf(1−Y/864).\widetilde F_{\ell-1}(Y)=1728^n f(1-Y/864).

This rational affine substitution preserves the splitting field. If ℓ\ell is prime, the monic supersingular jj-polynomial satisfies

Sℓ(Y)≡Y(λ+1)/2(Y−1728)(μ+1)/2 F~ℓ−1(Y)(modℓ).S_\ell(Y)\equiv Y^{(\lambda+1)/2}(Y-1728)^{(\mu+1)/2}\,\widetilde F_{\ell-1}(Y)\pmod\ell.

The two exponents record whether the supersingular invariants 00 and 17281728 occur. The prime-index requirement belongs to this modular reduction, not to the characteristic-zero Galois claim.

Now suppose n≥5n\ge5, and let CC be the smooth projective model of y2=f(x)y^2=f(x). Its genus is ⌊(n−1)/2⌋\lfloor(n-1)/2\rfloor. Combining the claimed group SnS_n with Zarhin’s published theorem gives

End⁡Q‾(Jac⁡C)=Z.\operatorname{End}_{\overline{\mathbb Q}}(\operatorname{Jac}C)=\mathbb Z.

Thus the Jacobian is absolutely simple. This application retains the preprint dependency even though Zarhin’s implication is established. Irreducibility by itself would not provide its group hypothesis.

Inspect all 8 connections and exact references
Evidence for each connection
ConnectionStatement and source
1Four Jacobi families: ±1/3, ±1/2 → Modular polynomial factorsConstruction / input

The four Jacobi polynomials become Kaneko–Zagier modular factors under the stated rational affine substitution and scaling.

2Four Jacobi families: ±1/3, ±1/2 → Irreducible with Galois group SₙDeduction · preprint

The preprint claims irreducibility and the full symmetric group for each of the four families in every positive degree.

  • J3 · Nguyen-Dang (2026)Theorem 1.1; §4, Proposition 4.8 and Appendix B; Theorem 5.12; §6.4, equations (6.4)–(6.5), Hexagon 2610.00468v1Preprint claim for all four parameter choices and every n≥1; no proof certification is asserted.Primary source
3Four Jacobi families: ±1/3, ±1/2 → Smooth model of y² = f(x)Construction / input

The distinct roots of f are the finite branch points of the smooth projective model of y²=f(x).

  • J4 · Zarhin (2000)Theorem 2.1; §§3–4, arXiv:math/9909052v2Use the characteristic-zero conclusion. The positive-characteristic theorem has an additional supersingular alternative.Primary source
4Irreducible with Galois group Sₙ → ANDConstruction / input

The symmetric-group input is the preprint-dependent hypothesis for this application.

5Smooth model of y² = f(x) → ANDConstruction / input

Zarhin’s argument uses the root permutation action on the Jacobian’s 2-torsion.

6Degree n ≥ 5; characteristic zero → ANDConstruction / input

The application is over Q and is restricted to n≥5.

7AND → Geometric endomorphism ring ℤDeduction

For a characteristic-zero polynomial of degree at least five with group Sₙ or Aₙ, Zarhin proves that every geometric Jacobian endomorphism is integer multiplication.

  • J4 · Zarhin (2000)Theorem 2.1; §§3–4, arXiv:math/9909052v2Use the characteristic-zero conclusion. The positive-characteristic theorem has an additional supersingular alternative.Primary source
8Geometric endomorphism ring ℤ → Absolutely simple JacobianDeduction

A nontrivial abelian subvariety would give an idempotent in the rational endomorphism algebra, whereas End⁰=Q has only 0 and 1.

  • J4 · Zarhin (2000)Theorem 2.1; §§3–4, arXiv:math/9909052v2Use the characteristic-zero conclusion. The positive-characteristic theorem has an additional supersingular alternative.Primary source

Sources and scope checked .

Questions

ClaimedPolynomial families

Are all four Kaneko–Zagier families irreducible with symmetric Galois group?

Scope. Integers n≥1n\ge1, α∈{−1/3,1/3}\alpha\in\{-1/3,1/3\}, β∈{−1/2,1/2}\beta\in\{-1/2,1/2\}, over Q\mathbb Q.

Define the shifted Jacobi polynomial

Jn(α,β)(x)=∑j=0n(n+αn−j)(n+α+β+jj)xj.J_n^{(\alpha,\beta)}(x)=\sum_{j=0}^n\binom{n+\alpha}{n-j}\binom{n+\alpha+\beta+j}{j}x^j.

The conjecture asks whether every Jn(α,β)J_n^{(\alpha,\beta)} in these four families is irreducible with Galois group SnS_n. These are the Jacobi normalizations of the Kaneko–Zagier families after their forced elliptic factors are removed. The 2026 preprint claims the full result; it is not used here as an established theorem.

References 3
Discuss this question →

Related topics

References

  1. Algebraic properties of Kaneko-Zagier lifts of supersingular polynomials

    Cullinan, John and Hajir, Farshid. Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society, 145(6), 2291–2304, 2017.

    Read the source
  2. Arithmetic of certain hypergeometric modular forms

    Mahlburg, Karl and Ono, Ken. Acta Arithmetica, 113(1), 39–55, 2004.

    Read the source
  3. On the Newton polygons of Kaneko–Zagier lifts of supersingular polynomials

    Cullinan, John and Gajek-Leonard, Rylan. Research in Number Theory, 2, Article 34, 2016.

    Read the source
  4. Arithmetic of Jacobi polynomials

    Nguyen-Dang, Khai-Hoan. Hexagon preprint, 2026.

    Read the source
  5. Supersingular j-invariants, hypergeometric series, and Atkin’s orthogonal polynomials

    Kaneko, Masanobu and Zagier, Don. AMS/IP Studies in Advanced Mathematics, 7, 97–126, 1998.

    Read the source
  6. Hyperelliptic Jacobians without complex multiplication

    Zarhin, Yuri G. Mathematical Research Letters, 7(1), 123–132, 2000.

    Read the source