Overview

  • What does Maeda’s conjecture assert for an individual Hecke operator?
  • Which weights and operators have been checked exactly?
  • How do local invariants separate Galois orbits at higher level?

Hecke polynomials

Let kk be a positive even integer and let Sk=Sk(SL2(Z))S_k=S_k(\mathrm{SL}_2(\mathbb Z)) be the space of cusp forms of weight kk. Assume d=dim⁡Sk>0d=\dim S_k>0. For m>1m>1, the Hecke polynomial is

Hk,m(X)=det⁡(XI−Tm∣Sk)∈Z[X].H_{k,m}(X)=\det(XI-T_m\mid S_k)\in\mathbb Z[X].

Its roots are the mm-th Fourier coefficients of the normalized simultaneous Hecke eigenforms, counted with multiplicity. Thus its irreducibility asks whether these eigenvalues form one Galois orbit of size dd.

References 1

Maeda’s conjecture

The formulation in Ghitza–McAndrew predicts that every Hk,mH_{k,m} above is irreducible over Q\mathbb Q with Galois group SdS_d. Their Theorem 1.5 verifies this for T2T_2 through weight 1400014000, and extends the result to specified sets of other indices. A computation through a finite weight does not settle the assertion for all weights.

One must distinguish this statement from the weaker assertion that the simultaneous eigenforms form one Galois orbit. A single Fourier coefficient need not generate the whole coefficient field merely by definition.

References 2

Example

In weight 2424, use the basis f=ΔE43f=\Delta E_4^3, g=Δ2g=\Delta^2. The first coefficients give

T2f=696f+20736000g,T2g=f+384g.T_2f=696f+20736000g,\qquad T_2g=f+384g.

Hence

H24,2(X)=X2−1080X−20468736.H_{24,2}(X)=X^2-1080X-20468736.

Its discriminant is 576⋅144169576\cdot144169. Since 3792<144169<3802379^2<144169<380^2, it is not a square. The polynomial is irreducible and its group is S2S_2. The matrix entries follow from the Fourier expansions; its determinant gives the displayed polynomial.

References 1
  • GhitzaMcAndrew2012 · §1, formula for the Hecke actionThe displayed weight-24 calculation is carried out in the atlas.Source

Higher level

At a fixed level N>1N>1, the newspace can have several Galois orbits. Tsaknias asks whether the number of non-CM newform orbits becomes constant as the even weight tends to infinity. For squarefree NN, a more precise prediction is 2ω(N)2^{\omega(N)} orbits for all sufficiently large weights, where ω(N)\omega(N) counts distinct prime factors.

Local types and Atkin–Lehner signs explain necessary decompositions. The 2026 preprint of Banerjee and collaborators studies quadratic nebentypus and proves lower bounds; it does not prove the general eventual-count conjecture. These questions concern simultaneous eigensystems, so their count should not be identified with the number of distinct factors of an arbitrary single Hecke polynomial without further hypotheses.

References 2

Inverse Galois theory

Wiese proves that Maeda’s conjecture would imply the following: for each positive even rr, the group PSL2(Fpr)\mathrm{PSL}_2(\mathbb F_{p^r}) occurs over Q\mathbb Q, ramified only at pp, for a density-one set of primes pp. This is a conditional consequence, not a proof of Maeda’s conjecture.

References 1

Local invariants

For prime-power or squarefree NN, Dieulefait–Pacetti–Tsaknias prove, for sufficiently large even kk,

NCM(N,k)≥∏p∣NLO(pvp(N)).\mathrm{NCM}(N,k)\ge\prod_{p\mid N}\mathrm{LO}(p^{v_p(N)}).

Here LO\mathrm{LO} counts local Galois orbits with compatible minimal Atkin–Lehner signs. Equality is asked in Question 4.5. At weight 12 and level 256, they find 12 non-CM orbits against a bound of 10; the discrepancy persists in their computations through weight 28. The authors therefore warn that additional invariants may be needed.

References 1

Questions

OpenPolynomial families

Do all level-one Hecke polynomials have full symmetric group?

Scope. Even k with d=dim S_k(SL_2(Z))>0; every integer m>1.

Maeda’s conjecture predicts that Hk,mH_{k,m} is irreducible and has Galois group SdS_d. The bound k≤14000k\le14000 for T2T_2 is verified; the universal assertion remains conjectural in the cited 2026 discussion.

References 2
Discuss this question →
OpenPolynomial families

Do non-CM Galois orbit counts stabilize with the weight?

Scope. Fixed N≥1; even weights k→∞; trivial nebentypus; the new subspace.

Tsaknias asks whether NCM(N,k)\mathrm{NCM}(N,k) is eventually constant. At squarefree level, Question 2.3 predicts 2ω(N)2^{\omega(N)} orbits. His additional multiplicativity proposal requires caution: Dieulefait–Pacetti–Tsaknias explain why local Galois actions need not vary independently and do not expect multiplicativity in general.

References 3
Discuss this question →

Related topics

References

  1. Experimental evidence for Maeda’s conjecture on modular forms

    Ghitza, Alexandru and McAndrew, Angus. Tbilisi Mathematical Journal, 5(2), 55–69, 2012.

    Read the source
  2. A possible generalization of Maeda’s conjecture

    Tsaknias, Panagiotis. In Böckle, Gebhard and Wiese, Gabor (editors), Computations with Modular Forms, Springer, Cham, Contributions in Mathematical and Computational Sciences, 6, 317–329, 2014.

    Read the source
  3. Towards a generalized Maeda conjecture for modular forms with quadratic nebentypus

    Banerjee, Debargha and Das, Dhrubajyoti and Das, Srijan and Mandal, Tathagata and Mondal, Sudipa. arXiv:2605.26771v2, 2026.

    Read the source
  4. An application of Maeda’s conjecture to the inverse Galois problem

    Wiese, Gabor. Mathematical Research Letters, 20(5), 985–993, 2013.

    Read the source
  5. On the number of Galois orbits of newforms

    Dieulefait, Luis Victor and Pacetti, Ariel and Tsaknias, Panagiotis. Journal of the European Mathematical Society, 23(8), 2833–2860, 2021.

    Read the source