Overview
- How do decomposition and inertia groups act on roots?
- Why does discriminant valuation one give a transposition?
- Why can a repeated reduction occur at an unramified prime?
Decomposition and inertia groups
Let be a finite Galois extension with group , and choose a prime above . Its decomposition group consists of automorphisms preserving . The inertia group consists of those acting trivially on the residue field . There is an exact sequence
Also . The local group is therefore a subgroup of the global Galois group. When is unramified, inertia is trivial and residue Frobenius lifts uniquely inside . At a ramified prime it determines a coset modulo inertia. Inertia fixes the reductions of integral roots, while possibly permuting roots that collide.
References 1
- Milne2020ANT · Theorem 7.58; Proposition 8.10Exact sequence, maximal unramified subfield, and identification with the local Galois group.Source
Tame inertia
In residue characteristic , inertia has a normal wild -subgroup and a cyclic quotient of order prime to . If the extension is tame, wild inertia is trivial, so inertia itself is cyclic.
For irreducible , put . If its splitting field is tame at , write , with residue degrees . A generator of inertia acts on the roots with an -cycle repeated times for each . Indeed, the decomposition orbit for has size , and splits into inertia orbits of size ; a cyclic generator traverses each orbit. The integers come from factorization in . Repeated factors of can also arise from the index .
For example, is Eisenstein over . Its root has valuation , forcing ramification index three. Adjoining a primitive cube root of unity is unramified at , since has squarefree reduction. The splitting field therefore has cyclic inertia of order three, acting as a three-cycle. Here has valuation two at : tame inertia gives a 3-cycle although the discriminant valuation is not one.
References 2
- Serre1979 · Ramification Groups, pp. 61–79Background for tame and wild inertia; the cycle description is the orbit consequence explained here.Source
- Milne2020ANT · Corollary 7.59 and the following paragraphCyclicity of the tame quotient and the criterion for tame ramification.Source
A simple discriminant prime
Theorem · simple discriminant prime
Let be monic and separable, with splitting field . If is odd and , then inertia at every prime of above has order two, and its nonidentity element acts as a transposition on the roots. Irreducibility is not required.
Proof
Multiplication by on the free -module has determinant . Valuation one means its Smith normal form has exactly one nonunit diagonal entry, so reduction modulo has cokernel dimension one. This cokernel is ; hence .
Since is odd, necessarily , where , is squarefree, and . Hensel's lemma lifts these coprime factors to over , with quadratic. The identity
and the unit factors and give . The splitting field is ramified quadratic; the squarefree reduction of makes its splitting field unramified. Their compositum therefore has inertia of order two, swapping precisely the two roots of .
References 2
- Milne2020ANT · Theorem 7.33; Proposition 7.50Hensel lifting and unramified extensions used in the explicit proof; the valuation-one deduction is supplied here.Source
- Serre1979 · Discriminant and Different, pp. 47–60; Ramification Groups, pp. 61–79Discriminants and local ramification framework.Source
Example
Example ·
The rational-root test proves irreducible: neither nor is a root. Its discriminant and bad-prime reduction are
Indeed, . The theorem supplies an inertia transposition at . Since is transitive, ; the transposition gives , so . The discriminant valuation proves nontrivial inertia; the repeated reduction alone would not suffice.
The index of an order
Remark
For monic irreducible with root and ,
Consider , with root . Modulo it becomes , yet has discriminant , so is unramified and its inertia group is trivial. The polynomial discriminant is : the repeated reduction comes from the index . If the polynomial discriminant has valuation one, the index is prime to .
A primitive subgroup containing a transposition is . Transitivity alone does not suffice.
References 1
- Milne2020ANT · Remark 2.25; Theorem 3.35Index-squared discriminant identity and the ramification–discriminant criterion.Source
Questions
Does a repeated root modulo p imply nontrivial inertia?
Scope. Monic integral polynomials over Q
No: modulo is a counterexample, because its root field is unramified at . The order index can account for repeated reduction; the valuation-one theorem excludes this obstruction.
References 2
- Serre1979 · Discriminant and Different, pp. 47–60The published discriminant and ramification theory proves the distinction used in this counterexample.Source
- Milne2020ANT · Remark 2.25; Theorem 3.35Index-squared identity and the ramification criterion.Source
Related topics
Connected diagrams
Browse all diagrams →Frobenius and factorization modulo primes
Squarefree reduction gives Frobenius cycle types; repeated reduction requires ramification and index information.
UsesDiscriminants, parity, and ramification
A simple discriminant prime isolates a ramified quadratic factor.
Applies toTransitivity, primitivity, and cycle criteria
An inertia transposition and primitivity imply the full symmetric group.
Contrasts withNewton polygons and Galois groups
Newton polygons constrain local factor degrees; inertia describes ramification permutations.
Linked from 1 articles
References
- Algebraic Number Theory (v3.08)
Milne, James S. Author course notes, 166 pages, 2020.
Read the source - Local Fields
Serre, Jean-Pierre. Springer, Graduate Texts in Mathematics, vol. 67, 1979.
Read the source
Comments
Any comments are welcome. Comments appear after the site owner approves them. Privacy policy.