Overview

  • How do decomposition and inertia groups act on roots?
  • Why does discriminant valuation one give a transposition?
  • Why can a repeated reduction occur at an unramified prime?

Decomposition and inertia groups

Let L/QL/\mathbb Q be a finite Galois extension with group GG, and choose a prime P\mathfrak P above pp. Its decomposition group DPD_{\mathfrak P} consists of automorphisms preserving P\mathfrak P. The inertia group IPI_{\mathfrak P} consists of those acting trivially on the residue field kP=OL/Pk_{\mathfrak P}=\mathcal O_L/\mathfrak P. There is an exact sequence

1⟶IP⟶DP⟶Gal⁡(kP/Fp)⟶1.1\longrightarrow I_{\mathfrak P}\longrightarrow D_{\mathfrak P}\longrightarrow\operatorname{Gal}(k_{\mathfrak P}/\mathbb F_p)\longrightarrow1.

Also DP≅Gal⁡(LP/Qp)D_{\mathfrak P}\cong\operatorname{Gal}(L_{\mathfrak P}/\mathbb Q_p). The local group is therefore a subgroup of the global Galois group. When pp is unramified, inertia is trivial and residue Frobenius lifts uniquely inside DPD_{\mathfrak P}. At a ramified prime it determines a coset modulo inertia. Inertia fixes the reductions of integral roots, while possibly permuting roots that collide.

References 1
  • Milne2020ANT · Theorem 7.58; Proposition 8.10Exact sequence, maximal unramified subfield, and identification with the local Galois group.Source

Tame inertia

In residue characteristic pp, inertia has a normal wild pp-subgroup and a cyclic quotient of order prime to pp. If the extension is tame, wild inertia is trivial, so inertia itself is cyclic.

For irreducible ff, put K=Q(α)K=\mathbb Q(\alpha). If its splitting field is tame at pp, write pOK=∏ipieip\mathcal O_K=\prod_i\mathfrak p_i^{e_i}, with residue degrees fif_i. A generator of inertia acts on the roots with an eie_i-cycle repeated fif_i times for each ii. Indeed, the decomposition orbit for pi\mathfrak p_i has size eifie_if_i, and splits into fif_i inertia orbits of size eie_i; a cyclic generator traverses each orbit. The integers eie_i come from factorization in OK\mathcal O_K. Repeated factors of f mod pf\bmod p can also arise from the index [OK:Z[α]][\mathcal O_K:\mathbb Z[\alpha]].

For example, x3−5x^3-5 is Eisenstein over Q5\mathbb Q_5. Its root has valuation 1/31/3, forcing ramification index three. Adjoining a primitive cube root of unity is unramified at 55, since x2+x+1x^2+x+1 has squarefree reduction. The splitting field therefore has cyclic inertia of order three, acting as a three-cycle. Here Δ(x3−5)=−675\Delta(x^3-5)=-675 has valuation two at 55: tame inertia gives a 3-cycle although the discriminant valuation is not one.

References 2
  • Serre1979 · Ramification Groups, pp. 61–79Background for tame and wild inertia; the cycle description is the orbit consequence explained here.Source
  • Milne2020ANT · Corollary 7.59 and the following paragraphCyclicity of the tame quotient and the criterion for tame ramification.Source

A simple discriminant prime

Theorem · simple discriminant prime

Let f∈Z[x]f\in\mathbb Z[x] be monic and separable, with splitting field LL. If pp is odd and vp(Δ(f))=1v_p(\Delta(f))=1, then inertia at every prime of LL above pp has order two, and its nonidentity element acts as a transposition on the roots. Irreducibility is not required.

Proof

Multiplication by f′f' on the free Zp\mathbb Z_p-module Zp[x]/(f)\mathbb Z_p[x]/(f) has determinant Res⁡(f,f′)=±Δ(f)\operatorname{Res}(f,f')=\pm\Delta(f). Valuation one means its Smith normal form has exactly one nonunit diagonal entry, so reduction modulo pp has cokernel dimension one. This cokernel is Fp[x]/(fˉ,fˉ′)\mathbb F_p[x]/(\bar f,\bar f'); hence deg⁡gcd⁡(fˉ,fˉ′)=1\deg\gcd(\bar f,\bar f')=1.

Since pp is odd, necessarily fˉ=(x−a)2hˉ\bar f=(x-a)^2\bar h, where a∈Fpa\in\mathbb F_p, hˉ\bar h is squarefree, and hˉ(a)≠0\bar h(a)\ne0. Hensel's lemma lifts these coprime factors to f=qhf=qh over Zp\mathbb Z_p, with qq quadratic. The identity

Δ(f)=Δ(q)Δ(h)Res⁡(q,h)2\Delta(f)=\Delta(q)\Delta(h)\operatorname{Res}(q,h)^2

and the unit factors Δ(h)\Delta(h) and Res⁡(q,h)\operatorname{Res}(q,h) give vp(Δ(q))=1v_p(\Delta(q))=1. The splitting field Qp(Δ(q))\mathbb Q_p(\sqrt{\Delta(q)}) is ramified quadratic; the squarefree reduction of hh makes its splitting field unramified. Their compositum therefore has inertia of order two, swapping precisely the two roots of qq.

References 2
  • Milne2020ANT · Theorem 7.33; Proposition 7.50Hensel lifting and unramified extensions used in the explicit proof; the valuation-one deduction is supplied here.Source
  • Serre1979 · Discriminant and Different, pp. 47–60; Ramification Groups, pp. 61–79Discriminants and local ramification framework.Source

Example

Example · x3−x−1x^3-x-1

The rational-root test proves f=x3−x−1f=x^3-x-1 irreducible: neither 11 nor −1-1 is a root. Its discriminant and bad-prime reduction are

Δ(f)=−4(−1)3−27(−1)2=−23,f≡(x−10)2(x−3)(mod23).\Delta(f)=-4(-1)^3-27(-1)^2=-23,\qquad f\equiv(x-10)^2(x-3)\pmod{23}.

Indeed, f−(x−10)2(x−3)=23(x2−7x+13)f-(x-10)^2(x-3)=23(x^2-7x+13). The theorem supplies an inertia transposition at 2323. Since G≤S3G\le S_3 is transitive, 3∣∣G∣3\mid |G|; the transposition gives 2∣∣G∣2\mid |G|, so G=S3G=S_3. The discriminant valuation proves nontrivial inertia; the repeated reduction alone would not suffice.

References 1
  • Serre1979 · Ramification Groups, pp. 61–79Local-group background; all numerical identities and the elementary group argument are verified directly here.Source

The index of an order

Remark

For monic irreducible ff with root α\alpha and K=Q(α)K=\mathbb Q(\alpha),

Δ(f)=disc⁡(K) [OK:Z[α]]2.\Delta(f)=\operatorname{disc}(K)\,[\mathcal O_K:\mathbb Z[\alpha]]^2.

Consider x2−18x^2-18, with root 323\sqrt2. Modulo 33 it becomes x2x^2, yet K=Q(2)K=\mathbb Q(\sqrt2) has discriminant 88, so 33 is unramified and its inertia group is trivial. The polynomial discriminant is 72=8⋅3272=8\cdot3^2: the repeated reduction comes from the index 33. If the polynomial discriminant has valuation one, the index is prime to pp.

A primitive subgroup containing a transposition is SnS_n. Transitivity alone does not suffice.

References 1
  • Milne2020ANT · Remark 2.25; Theorem 3.35Index-squared discriminant identity and the ramification–discriminant criterion.Source

Questions

SettledGalois group

Does a repeated root modulo p imply nontrivial inertia?

Scope. Monic integral polynomials over Q

No: x2−18x^2-18 modulo 33 is a counterexample, because its root field is unramified at 33. The order index can account for repeated reduction; the valuation-one theorem excludes this obstruction.

References 2
  • Serre1979 · Discriminant and Different, pp. 47–60The published discriminant and ramification theory proves the distinction used in this counterexample.Source
  • Milne2020ANT · Remark 2.25; Theorem 3.35Index-squared identity and the ramification criterion.Source
Discuss this question →

Related topics

References

  1. Algebraic Number Theory (v3.08)

    Milne, James S. Author course notes, 166 pages, 2020.

    Read the source
  2. Local Fields

    Serre, Jean-Pierre. Springer, Graduate Texts in Mathematics, vol. 67, 1979.

    Read the source