Overview

  • How does a simple resolvent root prove subgroup containment?
  • How is the cubic resolvent of a quartic constructed?
  • How are the five transitive quartic groups distinguished?

Invariant polynomials and coset actions

Let f∈K[x]f\in K[x] be separable, with roots Ξ±1,…,Ξ±n\alpha_1,\ldots,\alpha_n; suppose its Galois group is contained in G0≀SnG_0\le S_n. Choose Φ∈K[X1,…,Xn]\Phi\in K[X_1,\ldots,X_n] with formal stabilizer HH in G0G_0. Evaluate its orbit to obtain values Ξ²1,…,Ξ²m\beta_1,\ldots,\beta_m, where m=[G0:H]m=[G_0:H], and form

RΞ¦(T)=∏j=1m(Tβˆ’Ξ²j).R_\Phi(T)=\prod_{j=1}^m(T-\beta_j).

The actual Galois group permutes these values, so RΦR_\Phi has coefficients in the ground field. If the values are distinct, its irreducible factor degrees are the orbit sizes for this new action. A root in the ground field gives a fixed coset, hence containment of the Galois group in a conjugate of HH. More generally, a simple root in the ground field suffices even if other resolvent values coincide.

Simplicity is essential for this subgroup test: several cosets can have the same value without any one of them being fixed. A nonzero resolvent discriminant certifies distinctness; if it vanishes, different root expressions may be needed.

References 2

The cubic resolvent

For f=x4+ax3+bx2+cx+df=x^4+ax^3+bx^2+cx+d, the three partitions of its four roots into two unordered pairs give

Ξ²1=Ξ±1Ξ±2+Ξ±3Ξ±4,Ξ²2=Ξ±1Ξ±3+Ξ±2Ξ±4,Ξ²3=Ξ±1Ξ±4+Ξ±2Ξ±3.\beta_1=\alpha_1\alpha_2+\alpha_3\alpha_4,\quad\beta_2=\alpha_1\alpha_3+\alpha_2\alpha_4,\quad\beta_3=\alpha_1\alpha_4+\alpha_2\alpha_3.

Expanding ∏(Tβˆ’Ξ²i)\prod(T-\beta_i) in elementary symmetric functions yields

Rf(T)=T3βˆ’bT2+(acβˆ’4d)T+4bdβˆ’a2dβˆ’c2.R_f(T)=T^3-bT^2+(ac-4d)T+4bd-a^2d-c^2.

The action S4β†’S3S_4\to S_3 on the three pairings has kernel the normal Klein four-group. Moreover, Ξ²1βˆ’Ξ²2=(Ξ±1βˆ’Ξ±4)(Ξ±2βˆ’Ξ±3)\beta_1-\beta_2=(\alpha_1-\alpha_4)(\alpha_2-\alpha_3), with analogous formulas for the other differences. Their squared product proves disc⁑(Rf)=disc⁑(f)\operatorname{disc}(R_f)=\operatorname{disc}(f), so this resolvent is separable whenever ff is.

References 2

Quartic Galois groups

Assume char⁑Kβ‰ 2\operatorname{char}K\ne2 and ff is a separable irreducible quartic over KK. Then:

Resolvent over KKDiscriminant of ffGalois group
IrreducibleNonsquareS4S_4
IrreducibleSquareA4A_4
Splits completelySquareV4V_4
One linear factor and one irreducible quadraticNonsquareC4C_4 or D4D_4

Here D4D_4 denotes the dihedral group of order eight. In the last row, let r∈Kr\in K be the unique root of RfR_f. Then the group is C4C_4 precisely when both T2+aT+(bβˆ’r)T^2+aT+(b-r) and T2βˆ’rT+dT^2-rT+d split over K(Ξ”(f))K(\sqrt{\Delta(f)}); otherwise it is D4D_4.

References 2

Example

Example Β· f=x4+2x+2f=x^4+2x+2

Eisenstein at 22 proves irreducibility. The resolvent is Rf=T3βˆ’8Tβˆ’4R_f=T^3-8T-4. By the rational-root test a rational root would be one of Β±1,Β±2,Β±4\pm1,\pm2,\pm4; the six values, in the order βˆ’4,βˆ’2,βˆ’1,1,2,4-4,-2,-1,1,2,4, are βˆ’36,4,3,βˆ’11,βˆ’12,28-36,4,3,-11,-12,28. None is zero, so RfR_f is irreducible.

The discriminant is

256β‹…23βˆ’27β‹…24=1616=16β‹…101.256\cdot2^3-27\cdot2^4=1616=16\cdot101.

It is nonsquare. The first line of the classification gives Gal⁑(f/Q)=S4\operatorname{Gal}(f/\mathbb Q)=S_4.

References 1

Cyclic and dihedral examples

Example (cyclic group)

For f=x4+x3+x2+x+1f=x^4+x^3+x^2+x+1, translation gives f(x+1)=x4+5x3+10x2+10x+5f(x+1)=x^4+5x^3+10x^2+10x+5, which is Eisenstein at 55. Here

Ξ”(f)=125,Rf(T)=(Tβˆ’2)(T2+Tβˆ’1).\Delta(f)=125,\qquad R_f(T)=(T-2)(T^2+T-1).

The unique rational resolvent root is r=2r=2, and the discriminant field is Q(5)\mathbb Q(\sqrt5). The two test polynomials are T2+Tβˆ’1T^2+T-1 and (Tβˆ’1)2(T-1)^2. Both split over that field, so the group is C4C_4.

Example (dihedral group)

For f=x4βˆ’2f=x^4-2, Eisenstein at 22 proves irreducibility. Now

Ξ”(f)=βˆ’2048,Rf(T)=T(T2+8).\Delta(f)=-2048,\qquad R_f(T)=T(T^2+8).

Thus r=0r=0, the discriminant field is Q(βˆ’2)\mathbb Q(\sqrt{-2}), and the test polynomials are T2T^2 and T2βˆ’2T^2-2. The latter does not split there: a real element of this imaginary quadratic field is rational, while 2\sqrt2 is not. Hence the group is D4D_4, of order eight.

Both resolvents have the same factor degrees (1,2)(1,2). The extra quadratic-field test distinguishes their groups.

References 2

Relative resolvents

Factorization modulo a good prime determines a cycle type. Resolvent factorization describes orbits in another permutation action. The two tests give complementary restrictions; a rational resolvent root can identify a preserved partition that the observed cycle types do not determine.

In larger degrees, an absolute resolvent can be expensive to compute. Stauduhar's method descends through successive subgroup candidates using relative invariants. Fieker and KlΓΌners explain how to construct invariants from group structure and how to certify the relevant factors. A numerical approximation to an integer must be verified before it can certify a factorization.

References 2

Questions

SettledGalois group

How are cyclic and dihedral quartic groups distinguished?

Scope. Separable irreducible quartics over fields of characteristic not 2

For a reducible cubic resolvent, the discriminant first distinguishes the Klein-four case. In the remaining case, the Kappe–Warren criterion tests whether two specified quadratics split over the discriminant quadratic extension.

References 2
Discuss this question β†’

Related topics

References

  1. Computation of Galois groups of rational polynomials

    Fieker, Claus and KlΓΌners, JΓΌrgen. LMS Journal of Computation and Mathematics, 17(1), 141–158, 2014.

    Read the source
  2. The determination of Galois groups

    Stauduhar, R. P. Mathematics of Computation, 27(124), 981–996, 1973.

    Read the source
  3. Galois groups of cubics and quartics (not in characteristic 2)

    Conrad, Keith. Author-hosted expository note.

    Read the source
  4. Galois Theory

    Cox, David A. Edition 2. John Wiley & Sons, 2012.

    Read the source
  5. An Elementary Test for the Galois Group of a Quartic Polynomial

    Kappe, Luise-Charlotte and Warren, Bette. The American Mathematical Monthly, 96(2), 133–137, 1989.

    Read the source